The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

The Punditocracy of Unelected Technocrats

Post Syndicated from Bradley M. Kuhn original http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2013/04/06/meme-hustler.html

All this past week, people have been emailing and/or pinging me on IRC to
tell me to read the
article, The Meme Hustler by Evgeny Morozov
. The
article is quite long, and while my day-job duties left me TL;DR’ing it
for most of the week, I’ve now read it, and I understand why everyone
kept sending me the article. I encourage you not to TL;DR it any longer
yourself.

Morozov centers his criticisms on Tim O’Reilly, but that’s not all the
article is about. I spend my days walking the Free Software beat as a
(self-admitted) unelected politician, and I’ve encounter many spin doctors,
including O’Reilly — most of whom wear the trappings of advocates for
software freedom. As Morozov points out, O’Reilly isn’t the only one; he’s
just the best at it. Morozov’s analysis of O’Reilly can help us understand
these P.T. Barnum‘s
in our midst.

In 2001, I
co-wrote Freedom
or Power?
with RMS in response to O’Reilly’s
very Randian arguments
(which Morozov discusses). I remember working on that essay for
(literally) days with RMS, in-person at the FSF offices (and at his office
at MIT), while he would (again, literally) dance around the room, deep in
thought, and then run back to the screen where I was writing to suggest a
new idea or phrase to add. We both found it was really difficult to craft
the right rhetoric to refute O’Reilly’s points. (BTW, most people don’t
know that there were two versions of my and RMS’ essay; the original one
was published as a
direct
response to O’Reilly on his own website
. One of the reasons RMS and I
redrafted as a stand-alone piece was that we saw our original published
response actually served to increase uptake of O’Reilly’s
position. We decided the issue was important enough it needed a piece that
would stand on its own indefinitely to defend that key position.)

Meanwhile, I find it difficult to express more than a decade later how
turbulent that time was for hard-core Free Software advocates, and how
concerted the marketing campaign against us was. While we were in the
middle of the Microsoft’s attacks that GPL was an unAmerican cancer, we
also had O’Reilly’s the freedom that matters is the freedom to pick
one’s own license
meme propagating fast. There were dirty politics
afoot at the time, too: this all occurred during the same three-month
period
when Eric
Raymond called me an inmate taking over the asylum
. In other words,
the spin doctors were attacking software freedom advocates
from every side! Morozov’s article captures a bit of what
it feels like to be on the wrong side of a concerted, organized PR campaign
to manipulate public opinion.

However, I suppose what I like most about Morozov’s article is it’s the
first time I’ve seen discussed publicly and coherently a rhetorical trick
that spin doctors use. Notice when you listen to a pundit at their undue
sense of urgency; they invariably act as if what’s happening now is somehow
(to use a phrase the pundits love): “game changing”. What I
typically see is such folks use urgency as a reason to make compromises
quickly. Of course, the real goal is a get-rich-(or-famous)-quick scheme
for themselves — not a greater cause. The sense of urgency leaves
many people feeling that if they don’t follow the meme, they’ll be left in
the dust. A colleague of mine once described this entrancing effect as
dream-like, and that desire to stay asleep and keep dreaming is what
lets the hustlers keep us under their spell.

I’ve admittedly spent more time than I’d like refuting these spin doctors
(or, as Morozov also calls them, meme hustlers). Such work seems
unfortunately necessary because Free Software is in an important, multi-decade (but
admittedly not urgent 🙂 battle of cooption (which, BTW, every
social justice movement throughout history has faced). The tide of
cooption by spin doctors can be stemmed only with constant vigilance, so I
practice it.

Still, this all seems a cold, academic way to talk about the phenomenon.
For these calculating Frank Luntz types, winning is enough;
rhetoric, to them, is almost an end in itself (which I guess one might dub
“Cicero 2.0”). For those of us who believe in the cause, the
“game for the game’s sake” remains distasteful because there
are real principles at stake for us. Meanwhile, the most talented of these
meme hustlers know well that what’s a game to them
matters emotionally to us, so they use our genuine concern against
us at every turn. And, to make it worse, there’s more of them out there
than most people realize — usually carefully donning the trappings of
allies. Kudos to Morozov for reminding us how many of these emperors have
no clothes.

What Are We Breaking Now?

Post Syndicated from Lennart Poettering original https://0pointer.net/blog/projects/brno.html

End of February devconf.cz
took place in Brno, Czech Republic. At the conference Kay Sievers,
Harald Hoyer and I did two presentations about our work on systemd
and about the systemd Journal. These talks were taped and the
recordings are now available online.

First, here’s our talk about What Are We
Breaking Now?
, in which we try to give an overview on what we
are working on currently in the systemd context, and what we expect to
do in the next few months. We cover Predictable Network Interface
Names
, the Boot
Loader Spec
, kdbus, the Apps framework, and more.

And then, I did my second talk about The systemd
Journal
, with a focus on how to practically make use of
journalctl, as a day-to-day tool for administrators (these practical
bits start around 28:40). The commands demoed here are all explained in an earlier blog story of
mine
.

Unfortunately, the audience questions are sometimes hard or
impossible to understand from the videos, and sometimes the text on
the slides is hard to read, but I still believe that the two talks are
quite interesting.

MariaDB-Galera 5.5 released as stable

Post Syndicated from Monty original http://monty-says.blogspot.com/2013/03/mariadb-galera-55-released-as-stable.html

It’s now about one year ago since we released MariaDB 5.5. That proved to be an important release for MariaDB as it became popular with the users and ultimately also has been adopted by several important Linux distributions. But we have not stopped working since then, and now the MariaDB project is happy to announce something new again: the immediate availability of MariaDB Galera Cluster 5.5.29 stable release (GA).

As soon as we had released MariaDB 5.5 stable, we started planning with Codership Oy how to integrate their Galera replication technology with MariaDB 5.5. We have then worked together to merge their Write Set REPlication API into MariaDB, and gone through a rigorous testing program with beta and RC releases leading to today’s a stable release.

Elena from Monty Program and people from the MariaDB user community have tested those releases and provided feedback if they have found any bugs. Seppo Jaakola from the Galera team is a MariaDB Captain, which means he not only has commit rights to the MariaDB trunk, he also can participate in the MariaDB decision making together with other core contributors. (Note that MariaDB Galera Cluster currently still has it’s own branch in the MariaDB project on Launchpad. But I think it is likely that in the future this will become part of the main MariaDB branch and releases.)

This is one reason today’s release makes me very happy, because this is a great example of what we always wanted the MariaDB project to become. It also shows how we operate with many other companies and individuals. We want to be open and inclusive to anyone who can contribute great code, so that MariaDB can continue its MySQL heritage of being the most popular open source database. We want MariaDB to always include all the great innovation happening in the MySQL ecosystem.

About synchronous multi-master clustering

In the past weeks I have traveled in Germany, Korea and Sweden to speak about MariaDB, and it is clear to me that a lot of people have already heard of Galera and are already trying it out. But if you didn’t yet know about this technology, let me tell you why it is important.

MariaDB Galera Cluster provides synchronous multi-master replication. A simple way to explain what this means is to compare it with other alternatives that we have used for MariaDB high availability until today:

If you compare it to the traditional master-slave replication, it means that your data is safer in a Galera cluster because it is replicated immediately as part of the commit, without any delay. (This is why it is synchronous.) Also, in traditional master-slave replication you can do read-only scale-out, but with Galera you can read and write to any node. This makes life easier for application developers, because you don’t need to separate read-only transactions and write transactions. (This is why it is called multi-master.)

You can also compare it with DRBD, which is another popular High Availability solution for MariaDB and MySQL. The reason people use DRBD is usually because it is also synchronous replication, only it happens on the disk driver level. So it is used by people who want to be 100% sure they don’t lose a single transaction if they do a failover. But DRBD doesn’t give you any scale-out, since the spare node is so called cold standby, so you cannot use it for anything else but disaster recovery.

With MariaDB Galera Cluster we now provide “best of both worlds”: it is both synchronous, and you can use it for scale-out. And not just read-only scale out but multi-master scale-out.

Automatic node provisioning

There are many other benefits to Galera too, and you will be able to read more about them on the MariaDB blog. One nice little feature I think is also worth mentioning is the automatic node provisioning. One reason MySQL master-slave replication has become so popular is that it is quite easy to setup and understand. But Galera takes this even further, they completely automate the node provisioning process. My philosophy when I created MySQL was always to make everything very easy to the user, and I’m happy to see Galera shares this philosophy.

But it is not only nice, it is actually an important feature especially if you run MariaDB in the cloud. In the cloud you can save money by adding nodes to a cluster (scale out) when needed and then removing them (scale in) when you need less performance. You might do this every day, or every week depending on what kind of traffic your website gets. But to add and remove MariaDB nodes every day, you of course cannot do it manually every time.

For example many NoSQL systems talk about automatic node provisioning in their marketing so that they will sound “cloud compatible”. But MariaDB Galera Cluster does it too, so there is no reason to abandon SQL just to have automatic node provisioning.

Commercial support

When you have tested MariaDB Galera Cluster and decided that you like it, and want to run it in production, you of course want to make sure you have proper support in place. This is also important so that the developers can continue to work on the project and make it even better. Codership operates with a similar model like my company Monty Program, they develop the technology and do bug fixes, and they partner with SkySQL and other companies that support MariaDB in order to provide a complete and seamless support experience. You can contact SkySQL to discuss commercial support for both MariaDB and MariaDB-Galera.

You can also support MariaDB Galera Cluster development directly by donating via the MariaDB Foundation. If you specifically want to support Galera development, you should target your donation to “MariaDB Galera Cluster”.

systemd Hackfest!

Post Syndicated from Lennart Poettering original https://0pointer.net/blog/projects/hackfest.html

Hey, you, systemd hacker, Fedora hacker! Listen up! This Thu/Fri is the systemd
Hackfest
in Brno/Czech Rep, right before devconf.cz! On thursday we’ll talk about
(and hack on) all things systemd. And the hackfest friday is going to be a Fedora Activity Day,
so we’ll have a focus on systemd integration into Fedora.

You are invited!

See you in Brno!

The collective thoughts of the interwebz